[An earlier but very mangled version of this article appeared in the Train Gamer's Gazette, Volume 3, Number 3, Winter 1996.]
First off, I want to say that I've played a lot of three-player 1835, about half of it with this group, and I think it is a lot more playable with three than is 1830, Rail Baron, or other similar games: unlike those, the game divides well into three sides right from the beginning, and it doesn't have 1830's 60% ownership limit, which will really hose you in a three-player game.
But in our group, the games started getting too predictable. As Marcus put it: "I always get the Saxon (Sachsische), and the Saxon always gets screwed by the Bavarian (Bayerische) before it even floats." There's some truth to this. In our games, the Bavarian usually uses the Nürnberg-Fürth to build into Saxony right away, and if the Saxon doesn't float early, it can be hurt badly. And of course, in a three-player game, the two who didn't buy the director's share of the Saxon both own some Bavarian, so they favor this result and will not help float the Saxon, so it will not open until the third or fourth operating round.
We brainstormed and listed some other problems with the game.
First, when played as above, the Bavarian hardly ever builds in Bavaria after the first operating round! That doesn't seem historical or reasonable. The reason it has five station markers, in my view, is so that you can put them in Augsburg, Freiburg, and/or Stuttgart, and use them for runs in Bavaria, Baden-Württemberg, and into the Alsace-Lorraine (Elsaß-Lothringen). If the Bavarian doesn't build in Bavaria, all those station markers give it too much power. This problem also hoses the Württemberg. The Bavarian does need to be able to connect to the rest of Germany, but not right away.
(We have always played that, even when not playing this variant, the private companies are not exceptions to the "tile before token" rule, so the Bavarian can't build track north of Nürnberg on the first operating round. We also play that a company's home station goes down at the beginning of its first operating turn, NOT in the stock round when it floats. (Otherwise the Württemberg would always be at a serious disadvantage!) I have since found out that both of these are house rules.)
Second, some of the building restrictions seem petty or nonsensical. For one, Ludwigshafen/Mannheim is a yellow hex, so if you float the Badische early and green tiles don't come out, it can't run! (And in fact, 20 trains precede the first "3" in the standard game, and the Bavarian, Saxon, and the six minor companies have a total starting capacity of 20 trains, so green tiles can't possibly come out until the Badische floats!) For another, it ought to be possible to bridge the lower Elbe (the river that runs through Hamburg). [Marcus, who is from Germany, thought there were bridges there today, but I've since heard from another German who says there aren't. I don't know.]
Third, the Prussian director nearly always gets the Württemberg. (This is not a major problem in games with four or more players, but in a three-player game, one player usually gets at least 50% of the Prussian.)
All of this inspired us to come up with a variant which solves these problems and lets all three players start off on a roughly equal footing. (This does not mean the variant is limited to three, but it is primarily intended for three, and we've only played it a few times with more.) I call it the
The normal rules of 1835 apply, except as stated below.
1. The starting cash is increased to 2100M, divided among all players. Thus, in a three player game, each player starts with 700M. (In the standard game, there is just enough starting cash (if everyone cooperates) to buy the entire Share Starting Packet. So if you make the other changes but not this one, neither the Bavarian nor the Saxon will float for two or three operating rounds. This hands the game to whoever bought the most private and minor companies.)
2. The Nürnberg-Fürth private railway no longer exists. It is replaced in the Share Starting Packet by the new Köln Private Railway (KPR). The KPR pays income of 5M just like the Nürnberg-Fürth, but its build power is different: Any major company whose director owns the KPR may place a tile, once, and a station marker, once, in the Köln space, both for free. Either or both actions are allowed even if there is no connection to the company's existing track; both are in addition to any normal tile or token placement(s) by the major company. When both actions have been taken (using the KPR), the KPR closes.
3. The KPR, Ostbayerische, and Pfalzbahnen private railways now each come with a 10% share of either the Bavarian or the Saxon. You choose when you buy one of these. Take the "free" share from row 5 of the Starting Packet (see item 6).
4. The director's share of the Bavarian now comes with the München Bahn, a new private railway which is identical to the Leipzig-Dresdner Bahn in every way, except, of course, that it closes when the Bavarian buys a train. The two together still cost 184M.
5. These items in the Share Starting Packet change price:
6. A fifth row is added to the starting packet, consisting of enough Bavarian and Saxon shares to float both companies. (In other words, no one can buy from the last 50% of either company until both are floated.)
7. The Badische and Württemberg shares are swapped in the piles, so that the Württemberg must float before the Badische director's share can be bought.
8. The "Prussian shares are available" card stays in the first pile; that is, the four shares of Prussian stock that are for sale become available when the Württemberg (rather than Badische) director's share is bought. (In an earlier version of this variant, we put the card in the Hessian pile. That was a mistake. I think the designers intended that players should have to sink their money into the Prussian well before it starts operating, if they want to have a chance at controlling it.)
9. Two additional 2+2 trains (for a total of six) are added to the game. (In the one playtest where we increased the starting cash but didn't add extra trains, green tiles came out in the second operating round -- which is not even close to normal for 1835!)
10. Tiles number 14 and 15 (the green city tiles with one city which holds two station markers) may be upgraded to brown tile number 63.
11. Braunschweig is considered a green space, and may be upgraded to brown tile number 63.
12. The Nürnberg-Fürth space is considered a yellow space, and is special. The first tile played there (if any) must be green tile number 14. This may be upgraded to either of two brown tiles, 63 and 218. This is an exception to the normal upgrade rules. The space is still considered an "XX" space (so you can run a single train through both cities) until a tile is played there.
13. The Elbe river, west of Hamburg, may be crossed for a build cost of 50M. You pay when you complete the bridge by building in either hex C9 or B10, whichever is later. The 50M must be paid only once, the first time that such a bridge is completed. Building in either space without completing a bridge costs nothing. (John's simpler version: just have hex C9 cost 50M to build in. Why else would anyone build there?)
14. On any turn when a major company places two tiles (not counting builds enabled by the special power of a private railway), at least one of the two must connect to the company's original home station. (This is intended to limit the power of the KPR and Pfalzbahnen.)
15. At each opportunity to convert private and minor companies to Prussian shares, there is not just one round of "turns" to do this; the "conversion round" continues until everyone passes consecutively, just like a stock round.
16. (Added in version 2) The payouts for Schwerin and Oldenburg (preprinted brown cities) are increased to 10/20/30 (read this as if they were off-board runs).
17. (Optional) If you have 1841, play with its tiles as well as those of 1835. (1841 city tiles with letters other than Y, and mountain-pass tiles (zero value "cities"), cannot be used.)
This variant has produced an exciting game for our group. Here are some ideas of what to expect:
The most noticeable change is that there is a lot more building in the Rhine and Ruhr Valleys; but it usually is not cooperative building. (The #1 and #4 may be owned by the same player, but the KPR is always someone else, who does not hold much of the Prussian and does not want to build track that connects them all.)
The Saxon always has a presence in the Ruhr valley, and sometimes does not bother connecting to Berlin first. If its director does not hold the KPR, the Saxon often builds track from Leipzig or Fürth to Frankfurt. There is ample time to do this, because Phase 1 now lasts five or six rounds, and the Saxon opens in the first round.
The #6 usually builds the lower Elbe bridge, but not until green tiles are out (because its starting money doesn't allow for this). The #4 may help. As a result, Bremen gets built early, and the Mecklenburg and Oldenburg tend to be very well connected to everything else when they show up.
The Württemberg is more worthwhile than in the standard game, both because it opens sooner and because the Bavarian now builds track in Baden-Württemberg which the Württemberg can use, especially if the Bavarian's director does not hold the KPR. The Württemberg is also more able to block the Bavarian's runs than in the standard game, so everyone wants to own it, including the director of the Bavarian.
The Badische does about as well as normal. Even though there are more trains, because the Württemberg now precedes the Badische, it is much less likely that the Badische will have to take an operating turn before green tiles are available. And because the Badische has a choice of the two cities on its home tile, it cannot be totally blocked out of the Ruhr valley.
Everyone builds stations to block other people's runs, much more than in the standard game, especially in the Ruhr Valley. To deal with the blockage, bypass tracks east of Köln tend to get built.
Item 17, if used, makes it much easier to build bypasses, because some of the weird brown (orange) tiles in 1841 are useful in crowded locations such as the Frankfurt/Mainz/Mannheim area. It also means you have plenty of city tiles, not only for brown upgrades but for places like Kiel where the green tile may be scarce; and it adds the straight-through yellow Y city tile which is a useful option to have in most of the Y locations.
18xx Games and Variants
John David Galt's Home Page